« Labyrinth | Main | Brief Thoughts »

F.O.B.

Time Magazine has a really interesting article this week about Asian-American kids with parents who immigrated to the states. The article didn't say anything that I didn't already know: Growing up, we often felt different, isolated, embarrassed about our heritage, and it's taken years to fit in. I've always prided myself on the fact that I knew early on that I shouldn't abandon my Chinese roots. Or so I thought. After reading the stories of the people interviewed for the article, I thought, have I really embraced my heritage? All of the people said that they felt a sense of community once they went to college and found others in the same situation. They joined ethnic clubs and made friends with other Asian-Americans. However, I've been in college for three years now, and I haven't made one close Asian friend. All of my friends are still mostly white, and I'm even dating a white guy. Am I just in denial?

Everyone always compliments me on my Mandarin fluency, and it's usually followed with sad stories of immigrant children who refused to speak their native language once they came to America and eventually forgot how to speak it. It was no easy task for me; my parents said that one day I just came back from school and spoke in English. They played this game with me where they pretended they couldn't understand anything that came out of my mouth unless it was in Mandarin, and eventually I grew so frustrated that I just gave in. After that, I've always spoken Mandarin with my parents, but over the years it's become more Chinglish than Chinese, which makes me a little sad. But I'm trying.

Anyway, so I have the language down, and I've attempted to learn how to read and write Chinese. But after reading the article, I noticed that I haven't bothered to make any Asian friends, and now I'm trying to think why. One person said, "We all grew up feeling the tension between trying to be Asian and trying to be American." Maybe I still feel this tension, or maybe I've become so American that I've lost all hope of bonding with other Asian Americans. When I went to a meeting for OSU's Asian American Association, I saw a group of people who looked and acted just like me; we ate Chinese food and joked around in English. But I think that's what repelled me from ever going to another meeting. I didn't want to see Asian people speaking in English, because for some reason it felt wrong. I know I'm Asian and that I speak English, but I never actually see myself; all I see are my white friends speaking English and acting American. Of course, this makes no sense at all - how come I don't feel uncomfortable when my gazillion Indian friends speak English? Also, when I met these people, I thought of all the Asian American stereotypes, how we're all obsessed with cutesy material things and with image and fashion. I'm exactly the same way, and yet I was judging people as if I wasn't one of them.

This is why I think I'm an Asian American in denial; I am unwilling to accept other Asians who are exactly like me. Yet we have the most in common: our crazy parents, getting used to two customs, growing up in a white community... This is, of course, the result of me growing up in a white community with white friends, and it's sad. When I went to OSU I had a great opportunity to meet many Asian Americans; all I had to do was walk around the engineering buildings (yet another stereotype) to run into a horde of strangely dressed people talking furiously in Chinese. I've always been quick to point out that I'm the Asian girl, the odd one out in the group, and one could see that as a sense of pride in my heritage. And I am proud. But now I see that I am also the first to judge people by their race. I am ashamed.

Comments

Joanna ... come to the dark... errr...light...err...WHITE SIDE!

hello!!!!!

for me... i feel uncomfortable around other korean-americans (not so much around asian-americans not korean) because i'm constantly measuring how korean i am... compared to them. am i more korean then them or less korean? i constnatly feel like im either competiting or lacking... i either feel good or bad... in both situations. whether its yay im so korean or man im not korean enough.... hanging out other korean-americans just reminds me that im always aware of where on that stupid little dash im hovering on.

if your interested in thinking about it more theres a book called "yell oh! girls". I am still in the middle of reading it, because i get too emotionally involved in the stories and always end up crying. but im silly like that. its a collection of stories from various asian-american girls from like 18-24 about their asian-american identity. mainly short stories and personal essays. very touching. give it a try ^__^

oh wow.... this entry... it's so me it's ridiculous lolz.

The way I feel around other Korean-Americans is pretty much the same as the girl above me, Anna says. I always feel like other Koreans look down on me because I'm not exceptionally fluent in the language and haven't lived in Korea, and don't really want to go. I feel like an invalid around them because they're so in touch with the culture and everything and I'm like, not.
And 3 couples I know that are all our age recently got engaged these past 2 weeks (insane!) and so my mother and I talked about marriage for a few minutes the other day, and I seriously cannot see myself with a Korean guy. Ever. Like, it's not even an option for me.
And you know how I'm always crackin jokes and hatin on Asians. I'm horrible lol.

But I have this group of 3 korean girls, granted 2 of them are mixed, but close enough lol and we've all been really close friends for over 12 years now. So this shows that it is possible to have close friendships with other asians. But I don't have any asian friends here because most of the asians here ONLY hang out with other people from their country. I try to embrace both American and Korean cultures, whereas the asians here live in America and are fluent in English but try to embrace only their culture, and hang out with only other people with their same ethnicity here. They kind of shut themselves off from the rest of the world, and that's what turns me off.

I dunno... that's just me and my opinion though.
I mean, obviously you have asian friends like Katherine, me, David, who was that other guy I met that one time... Frank? and others, so you definitely have the capability of making asian friends. Maybe you didn't make any asian friends at OSU because of other factors like personality or something and not just their ethnicity persay.

But the important thing is that you're trying. You try with your family and you're still taking Chinese at Kent, yes? Just keep trying and hang in there!

Yea, I'm uncomfortable around other Chinese-Americans too, because I never know the level of Chinese or American they are, and I feel like I can't relate to those who are more Chinese that I am. Well I don't know, but I'm going to attempt to make more Asian friends. Or at least be part of an Asian community somewhere, in church or at school or whatever.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)